Evolution settles defamation case with C&K law firm

Evolution reaches settlement in defamation lawsuit

Evolution has reached a settlement with law firm Calcagni & Kanefsky (C&K) in its defamation lawsuit over a 2021 report about its games.

Evolution reaches settlement in defamation lawsuit

As a result of the settlement, private intelligence agency Black Cube has now been left as the only remaining defendant.

How the case started

The 2021 report was published under C&K’s name and alleged that Evolution’s live casino games could be accessed in US-sanctioned countries and other jurisdictions where they were not allowed. Its release wiped billions of dollars from Evolution’s share price, and the Swedish supplier responded with a defamation lawsuit. Over years of court proceedings, Evolution won rulings forcing the parties behind the report to be identified, which revealed that Black Cube had prepared it on behalf of Evolution’s rival Playtech.

What happened at the November 17 hearing

The latest hearing focused on a challenge to the lawsuit under the Uniform Public Expression Protection Act (UPEPA), New Jersey’s anti-SLAPP law. Anti-SLAPP laws are designed to stop lawsuits from being used to silence speech on matters of public interest, and a successful challenge can end a case before it reaches trial. The hearing had been scheduled for November 16 but was pushed back by a day without explanation, and when it opened, C&K’s lawyers told the court the firm had settled with Evolution.

Black Cube’s lawyers asked to see the agreement, arguing that its terms and timing matter for the rest of the case. C&K’s counsel refused to hand it over without a court order, citing confidentiality, and Judge John Porto said further written arguments may be needed within around 30 days. Black Cube’s team described the deal as C&K effectively surrendering and said their understanding was that it contains no financial component. If that is accurate, C&K has left the case without any money changing hands, a notable retreat for the firm that put its name to the report.

The judge also asked whether the constitutionality of UPEPA had been considered, noting that a search of case law turned up few rulings on the question anywhere in the US.

Black Cube’s defense

Black Cube argued that the report was based on the truth and should therefore be protected under UPEPA. Its lawyers pointed to the time C&K spent vetting the material, including attempts to play Evolution’s games from the jurisdictions in question and secret recordings in which Evolution staff and partners allegedly discussed activity in those markets.

Black Cube has also succeeded in having Evolution’s internal investigation by Spectrum Gaming disclosed, and argues that it supports the allegations rather than clearing the company. Evolution has disputed this throughout, saying much of Black Cube’s evidence is unreliable and that Spectrum could not corroborate many of the report’s main claims.

Where Playtech fits in

Evolution has already asked to add Playtech as a defendant, but the court ruled that this cannot happen until the UPEPA challenge is resolved. The outcome of the current hearing therefore matters for all three companies. If the judge rejects Black Cube’s challenge, Playtech is likely to be brought into the case, and the parties would then move into discovery, the stage where each side has to hand over evidence before trial. Playtech’s shares fell sharply and recovered within minutes shortly before the hearing began on November 17, although no reason has been given for the movement.

Alla Basentsyan
Content Writer

As a content writer at AffPapa, Alla focuses on daily coverage of iGaming news, writes in-depth articles on the most relevant topics of the sector, and presents insights from industry professionals through dedicated interviews. She combines her background in research with an engaging and informative approach to help readers stay up-to-date with everything that’s happening in global iGaming markets.