Ashton’s widow, Annie Ashton, and the couple’s two children brought the claim against TSE Malta LP, the Flutter entity behind Betfair, arguing that the operator failed to act on warning signs in his betting. Ashton deposited around £10,600 across various accounts and lost about £7,500 in the first four months of 2021, with losses on Betfair exceeding £5,600 in March alone, when the company’s automated safer gambling system sent him 4 messages but no direct contact followed.
In his November 13 judgment, Justice Jonathan Swift preferred the evidence of Betfair’s psychiatric expert, who found that betting records alone could not establish a clinical diagnosis, over the family’s expert, who concluded Ashton met eight of nine DSM-5 criteria for gambling disorder.
Jonathan Swift, High Court Judge, stated:
“There is no sufficient evidence to support the conclusion that Mr Ashton did suffer from gambling disorder and that being so, no possible basis on which the requirement for foreseeability could be met.”
A Flutter UK & Ireland spokesperson said:
“While we welcome the court’s ruling, this is a tragic case and we once again offer our sincere condolences to Mrs Ashton and her family.”
The judge rejected a general duty to protect customers based on the Gambling Commission’s social responsibility rules, noting that the Gambling Act 2005 states a breach of the regulator’s code doesn’t on its own give rise to civil liability. Instead, he said a duty could arise where an operator knew a customer had been diagnosed with gambling disorder or where betting showed a complete loss of control, in which case it should stop providing services.





